Sometimes the most interesting beauty products are also the simplest; they’re those staples in our routines that we’d never leave the house without, yet we tend to forget they’re even there. Black eyeliner is one of those staples for many of us. From making those peepers pop at work to creating a glamorous and sultry night-out look, black eyeliner just might be the most versatile product in your makeup bag. At the MichellePhan.com HQ, we decided to round up the team and compare 4 classic brands:

So how did all four eyeliners measure up"
Smudge - A felt tip is always good for smudging, and if you like the look of a smudge across the upper lash line, Revolution‘s eyeliners are the way to go. You won’t get a dainty, delicate line with this thick pen, but they do have liquid liners and thin felt tips to choose from too. Luckily, they’re all a steal. Waterline - Given how smoothly NARS Larger Than Life Longwear Eyeliner glides on for a more defined and dramatic application, it’s an obvious pick for the waterline – their long-wearing formula makes it perfect for areas that other liners slide right off of. This one is versatile for a variety of looks including natural smokey eyes too – no wonder it’s considered a classic.
Precise Lines – Jouer Kitten Liner lives up to its name. The small, gentle pen tip makes it ideal for precise winged liner, including cat eyes, but it’s also the one you want to...